Gatsby’s Pizza
4450 Bonita Beach Rd SW, Bonita Springs, FL, 34134
Gatsby’s Pizza Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Bonita Springs for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Bonita Springs for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Bonita Springs for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
4450 Bonita Beach Rd SW
Bonita Springs, FL, 34134 - Phone (239) 676-5011
- Website https://gatsbysbuckeyepizza.com/
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
Sorry, Store hours have not been updated. If you are the owner of this restaurants. Please update the store hours.
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : No
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Parking : Private Lot
Bike Parking : Yes
Wheelchair Accessible : Yes
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Average
Alcohol : Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating : Yes
Wi-Fi : No
Has TV : Yes
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : Yes
Categories
Pizza
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
John R.
Place has moved to 4450 Bonita Beach Rd, Suite #10, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 (239) 676-5011. I updated the business info and let's see if it sticks. (See a photo of the new info I posted in the business photos section) The thin crust pizza they serve is somewhere between the thinnest I have had in the NY tristate area and what would be a 'normal' pizza there. Generally speaking a thumbs up, well worth a visit, and a surprising find in an area with very little choice if this is what you are looking for.
(4)Eric M.
I just don't understand why this place gets any good reviews. I ate here last night with my niece and nephew and we were very disappointed at the pies. When we ordered were told there's a 35 minute wait, there were 6 other people in the place. I asked why so long a wait the waitress said we make them to order, really??? I was hoping for frozen pizza!! I mumbled okay and thought this must be great pie for such a long wait. First, our waitress was nice but frazzled. We ordered 2 pies, one was a Margherita and the other was their regular large pie with 2 toppings. The Margherita pie had no sauce, cheese very little basil and sliced chunks of barely ripe tomato. This not how they are made. The other pie had sauce and cheese with half the pie with pepperoni and the other half jalapeño slices that looked either canned or just pre-cooked. The thin crust was bland and stiff very little air almost cracker like. After the long wait the kitchen put our pies on a pass through and called out order ready, the 2 waitresses left our pies sitting out on the ledge with no heating element for 8 minutes, passing by 4 times before bringing them to us!!! So lukewarm pizza that was no very good to start with was even worse. My family ate it anyway we were starving. Just so you understand I'm a chef who in my spare time creates artisan pizza. But I'll eat anything I love White Castle. So I'm not a snob! Yes, I do live in NYC and this was one of my least favorite pies I ever had... Small and expensive with tip for just 2 pies $40. I have had better pie at pizza hut and I'm not joking. Try Enzo's across the street I hear their pie he better. I'm still looking for a decent pie in SW Florida.
(1)Marcia N.
Ordered pickup pizza "large" more like a medium told it would be 30 minutes because they were very busy.. Got there in 25 place was empty .. Pizza each topping $1.95 each so &25.50... Brunt---Cold---Expensive! Don't waste the time... Go to Joey's
(2)Scott P.
Florida's motto should be "Home of Bizarre Restaurant Experiences." Add Gatsby's to the list. My suggestion...instead of going to Gatsby's, pull out of the parking lot, take a left and go to Hot Space to get your pizza. I certainly would have liked to have tried the pizza at Gatsby's. We ordered pizza on a Friday night and were told that it would take about 20 minutes. We took about 30 minutes to get there to pick it up. There was a strange sign on the door that said that the place was closed due to a family illness. When we walked in, there was one confused waitress with a 1/2 full restaurant and 2 people in the kitchen. She informed us that the ingredients for the pizza just arrived (thinking dough, cheese and sauce, but not exactly sure if there was a "special" ingredient they were missing). She did not seem too concerned about the family illness though, so I'm not sure the stories were quite straight. She said they could start making our pizza now, but it would take 20 minutes, "but probably longer." We walked out and went down the street to Hot Space (which I highly recommend!) to grab a great pizza in a short amount of time. Again, save your time and steer clear of this place.
(1)Eliizabeth E.
Very good pizza! The thin crust was crispy but not the least bit burnt. The sauce was great not to sweet or spicy just good flavor. Lots of pepperoni and green peppers on top! The pizza was ready on time for pick up.
(4)Kathi B.
Stopped in for a pizza last Friday night. Honestly the experience was so bad we thought maybe we were on candid camera. The manager didn't acknowledge anybody who was waiting for a table for at least 30 minutes, we waited almost an hour for a table despite the fact that there were several open tables. When the waitress came by about 20 minutes later we were told they were out of about a dozen items including Coke and Diet Coke. We settled on mellow yellow and a pizza, only to find out another 45 minutes later that, were out of absolutely everything required to make a pizza. Do not go.
(1)Kelly C.
Do not wast your time. Go the Crust in the Pavillion. Canned mushrooms on a pizza - really? Isn't that pizza 101. Terrible service, bartender looked at me like I was putting him out bc my wine glass had lip imprint on it & I ask for a new. Enzo's is wayyyy better too.
(1)Elle T.
Visited here tonight for dinner, ordered a simple pizza, 45 minutes later still no pizza but tables around us were being served.New waitress never checked on us or updated us on our order. Only when we stood up to leave did they finally have our pizza ready. I told her we were leaving & to box it up. Manager could care less. Pizza was actually very good but not worth the 45 min wait.
(1)Claire D.
Eh, bad service, good pizza. What are you going to do?
(3)Todd G.
Great pizza. Tons of toppings. Pepperoni was almost too spicy. Large size isn't quite as large as you normally expect.
(4)R C.
Comfortable place, friendly service, clean place. Food is mediocre (not bad, not great). Pizza reminded me of Dominos. Caesar salad dressing from a jar - not good. I had hoped for better. Safe place (food wise) to bring the kids but I won't be back.
(2)Mike H.
Really disappointed!!!! Very expensive pizza that was basically burnt!! Will post photo.
(1)Ted G.
Went to Gatsby's last night; Worst restaurant experience ever. Waitress tried hard but the kitchen couldn't get anything right. After everyone at our table got served I sat there for 1/2 hour asking for my order. Manager seemed helpless. Save your money.
(1)Paul T.
Pizza is good but good luck trying to order to go. The last two times I tried to order I was put on hold and then told they wouldn't take my order. For some reason they have an issue with taking a to go pizza order.
(3)Adam V.
The resturante is a fair size. The tables themselves are somewhat flimsy and cheesy but the food is great. The pizza was awesome. It had a ton of toppings. The pizza was round but the cuts were square which was neat in itself. The wedding soup wants very good.
(5)Nick P.
Great pizza! Always crave more. Every time I visit Naples I must have one of their pizzas!
(5)Jason P.
Chicago Style pizza. If you are from Chicago or the Midwest, this is it. Yes, it is cut in squares....only someone from Chicago would understand. Anyway, pizza is good here.....not great, but good
(5)Don S.
Pizza is great if you like thin crust. Reheats nice also in the microwave. It doesn't get all soggy. Had the meatball hoagie also an it was good but not great. The pizza though is really good!
(4)Susan G.
It's a Friday night and everyone is happy. Let's go out for pizza! We were a large group of 12 but waited 30 minutes patiently for seats. Once seated, we waited yet another 20 minutes before we had a waitress. Orders were taken. Half our table got drinks. Half waited another 20 minutes for their drinks. Half of our table received their dinners. Half of our table waited another 20 minutes for theirs. Unfortunately we were the people awaiting our food and drinks and watching our friends enjoy theirs. No explanation, no apology. Food was mediocre, but service was HORRIBLE. Asked at the bar if the owner was present. Nope. Manager? Nope! On a Friday night? Bad move owner/manager! Don't expect to see this place in business much longer. Blech!
(1)Andy K.
Solid pizza! Loved it. Reminded me of pizza king or donatos. I really enjoy the thin crust cut up in little squares with the finely chopped sausage. Will be back for sure!
(5)Adrienne K.
Go Buckeyes! Ohio State fans represent here! Delicious thin crust pizza...wonderful neighborhood feel...delish!!
(5)Kevin M.
This pizza was average in my mind. Part if it being that it got cold driving home in traffic on bonita beach road. That said it was still lacking in my opinion. Mushrooms were like can mushrooms and there was hardly any pizza sauce. Pepperoni was not very spicy or flavorful, but not bad by any means. The inside of the place seemed pretty cool and being from Columbus Oh I felt at home picking up the pizza. This is due to all the Buckeye paraphernalia on the walls. Wish we could find a go to pizza spot here!
(3)Charles J.
Remember that scene in Lethal Weapon 2 when they get take out food and Joe Pesci says " you always get f....... In the drive through?" Well that's Gatsby's. Terrible service. Incompetence unchained. If you want pizza for dinner, go ANYWHERE ELSE.
(1)Hp B.
The best thin pizza in Naples. Ohio State hdqtrs. Ask for Craig or Jackie. But Jose is the best mgr. Get white pizza. Tell them burgermaven sent you. Because of the excellent press the place does get a little crowded during prime hours. Craig said they had ordered a new larger pizza oven and will improve service times. That will be a big help. I'll give it 5 stars after they 'speed' up service. I still think its worth waiting for.
(4)Brian B.
The pizza is good...just like Tommy's in Columbus. That's why this entire experience makes me even more frustrated. I called in for a carryout at 8:35 pm on Monday to make sure they were still open. I asked the guy on the phone when they stop taking orders and he says 8:45. I tell him " I'm calling back in 1 minute...literally one minute" so I could finalize the exact order with my family. Big mistake. I called back at 8:36 and the guy had shutoff their phone system! Unbelievable! I guess their business is so good that they didn't need my order or the dedicated employee who answered the phone had big plans on a Monday night. The problem is this is consistent with the rude service we had as a family the last time we ate in-house...that's why I wanted to do carry out.
(1)Shirley H.
I just recently saw that there is a new Gatsby's Pizza opening on Bonita Beach Rd in Bonita Springs. I went by the other day but no one seems to know when it's going to open. They said that they have been in this new location since August but not ready to open yet. Does anyone have any information on this place yet? I loved the pizza when they were on Wiggins Pass in Naples.
(5)Sarah F.
Got take-out pizza from here on our last visit to Naples. Be prepared for a longer-than-chain wait for your pizza, even take-out. There are a good variety of topping options across both meats (including chicken) and veggies. They cut the pizza into squares vs. traditional triangular slices, which I don't love. The taste/quality was good, but nothing terribly memorable or unique.
(3)Debbie B.
Best pizza in Naples area. Fresh ingredients and Greg the owner is amazing. Family Friendly and Fun
(5)Jamie R.
Now moved just a few miles from Gatsby's former location in North Collier to a larger space in south Lee. The dream for the perfect pie just gets bigger. Despite daunting illness, the family's operating a fine pizzeria along the Bonita Beach Blvd corridor that connects the beach with US41. My favorite is the super fresh Margarita pizza. Lots of cheese beds fresh tomato and basil on a thin crust. Gatsby's not only a place for great pizza, it's a living testimonial to perseverance, hard work, and confidence in what can be done. Kudus, Greg & family!
(5)Rick H.
STRIKE THREE !!!! YOUR OUT ! I now know why they don't have a medium pizza on the menu, it's BECAUSE they call it a large. A few pieces of pepperoni, very small amount of sausage and almost no cheese. Pizza was a joke, I'm done. I'm embarrassed they aline themselves with the Buckeyes.
(1)Chryss A.
Seriously best pizza in Florida (and it's because it's actually from Ohio)! This Famous central Ohio pizza has retired to southwest Florida after more than 30 years making pies in Ohio. This is how pizza is suppose to taste! We drive 20 miles to get it and honestly would drive further. This is the best!
(5)Chris K.
In a new location and still hands down the best pizza in Naples! Thin crust but not so crisp that it's crunchy. The topings are more than generous. Highly recommend Gatsby's, we and every member of or family come here whenever we're in Naples. It doesn't hurt that the owners are almost always there and are awesome people.
(5)